The coaches - Where do they
come from?
-
Introduction:
African coaches vs. European
or South American experts - complicated situations in African nations consisting
of various ethnic groups are one important reason to rely on a 'neutral'
outsider
-
Facts:
Almost half of the Nations
Cup winning coaches have been Africans, third have been East Europeans.
Those have vanished but
the Nations Cup 2000 will unlikely be won by an African coach: most big
teams arrive with a West European in charge
Introduction
A big topic in African
football is the question of coaching of national teams. The question whether
to put faith in a local coach or to hire a foreign 'expert'.
Historically seen,
coaches from Europe or South America had had an edge in knowledge of modern
training methods and football ideologies. This did not necessarily mean,
the application on African teams was always the best way.
But another point
plays a big role in the decisions: African nations consist of differents
ethnics with different backgrounds and even different languages. So a coach
alway stems from one group and this often becomes a problem even if only
interpreted into it from outside. A foreign coach is something like neutral
and usually has some authority advantage in the beginning of his term.
Today the situation
has become more complicated: successful foreign coaches often have no big
names, and big names might find it hard to cope with the different circumstanzes.
The foreign coaches actually working often have even different methods.
But many players arrive from Europe from big clubs with prominent football
teachers. Sometimes they even do not accept coaching philosophies in the
National team when the coach is a foreigner.
Facts
At the Nations Cup
foreign coaches have not been as successful as you might think: 10 of 21
Nations Cup winners achieved the goal without the help of coaches from
other continents. Of the other eleven, one coach had been from Brazil and
10 from Europe. Those 10 include 7 (until 1984) stemming from the then
communist East European states. Only after 1984 3 West European coaches
from Wales, France and Netherlands have won the Cup.
Ghana has won all
their four titles with coaches from home. Now they are trying different,
but now they also have a majority of European based players.
The coaching situation at
the Nations Cup 1998:
African coaches |
Non-African coaches |
Group A |
Côte d'Ivoire (Martin
Tia Gbonké) |
Ghana (Giuseppe Dossena,
Italy)
Cameroon (Pierre Lechantre,
France)
Togo (Gottlieb Göller,
Germany) |
Group B |
South Africa (Trott Moloto)
Algeria (Nasser Sandjak)
DR Congo (Basilua Lusadisu
Médard) |
Gabon (Antonio Dumas, Brazil) |
Group C |
Zambia (Ben Bamfuchile) |
Egypt (Gerard Gili, France)
Burkina Faso (René
Taelman (Belgium)
Peter Schnitger (Germany) |
Group D |
Congo (David Memy) |
Nigeria (Jo Benfrere, Netherlands)
Tunisia (Francesco Scolgio,
Italy)
Morocco (Henri Michel, France) |
It would be only logical the
winning coach would be an European: Not only do they outnumber domestic
coaches, all favorites apart from South Africa are coached by Europeans.
Conspicious also: The once
successful Eastern European coaches have disappeared completely. Italy,
relatively meaningless as colonial power, has started to have some impact
now. |